It seems islands were not properly imported. The importer expected islands to have namespace ID = 0, but this was changed in more recent times because of database restores not automatically treating ID = 0 well. I have updated the importer to accept both the Island ID and 0 as acceptable namespace IDs for Island pages in the future. For now, our islands were imported as regular pages. I may or may not write a small script to convert them. I'm supposed to be on vacation right now.